Watershed Highlight 2: Long-term Implications of BMP Implementation in the Sny Magill Creek Watershed
Three separate projects were carried out spanning the time period of 1988 to 1999 to improve water quality in the Sny Magill Creek watershed. The cumulative adoption percentages and total levels of key BMPs implemented during the 1990s through the Sny Magill Hydrologic Unit Area (HUA) and Sny Magill Creek Watershed projects are listed for selected years in Table 1.

Table 1
Cumulative percentages of total BMP adoption that was cost shared by year (expressed as a percentage of the total amount implemented as given in the bottom line).
Year Terrace Subsurface tile Sediment basin Grade stabilization Field border Contouring
1992 28 22 28 92 16 11
1995 65 65 79 93 99 53
1998 95 94 98 100 100 100
2001 100 100 100 100 100 100
Total Units 269,585 ft 160,345 ft 61 total 90 total 26,700 ft 1,907 ac

The cumulative adoption of terraces in the watershed is also shown in Figure 6 for 1991, 1995, and 2005. A paired watershed approach was used to assess Sny Magill Creek water quality improvements from 1992 to 2001 (Fields et al., 2005). Analysis of Sny Magill stream flow and water quality data collected during 1991-2001 was performed using a pre/post statistical model. The statistical results indicated that discharge at the watershed outlet increased by 8% over the 10-year period; this could partly be due to routing of runoff water captured by terraces into surface inlet drains (that are often installed just upslope of a terrace) and to the stream. The statistical analysis also showed that the BMPs installed during the 1990s resulted in a 42% decrease in turbidity but only a 7% decrease in total suspended solids (TSS). The TSS results imply that stream bed and bank erosion continued to contribute significant sediment loads to Sny Magill Creek, even after BMP installation reduced sediment delivery from upland areas. The increase in discharge may have further magnified the in-channel sediment contributions. Overall, the TSS results suggest that a long lag time may occur before the full impacts of the installed BMPs are realized. The statistical analysis also revealed that an increase in nitrate concentrations of 15% was found at the SMCW outlet. This indicates greater N leaching, which is consistent with increased infiltration of rainfall that naturally results when conservation practices successfully decrease surface runoff. However, the nitrate concentration level still only slightly exceeded 3 mg/L at the end of the 10-year time period, which is quite low compared with the concentrations measured in most other Iowa stream systems, including the South Fork and Squaw Creek watersheds.

Figure 6
Cumulative additions of terraces to specific land tracts in the Sny Magill Creek Watershed.